Should Chris Van Hollen replace Chuck Schumer as Senate Majority Leader?

By Billy Wimsatt, Founder and Executive Director

Senate Democrats pick their next leader by secret ballot on December 1. Here’s why MVP partners and donors are making their voices heard for Chris Van Hollen.

Drop Site whip count for Senate Majority Leader: Schumer leaning 16, Van Hollen leaning 10, undecided 23, no position 6, race not called 1; 28 votes to win

Screenshot: Drop Site

MVP friends -

We’re holding an emergency donor briefing on Friday, November 20, about something that could change the future of our country: supporting Chris Van Hollen in his challenge to replace Chuck Schumer as the next Senate Majority Leader.

Emergency Briefing: Replace Schumer?
Friday, November 20
Noon-1 pm ET • 11 am-Noon CT • 10-11 am MT • 9-10 am PT

This is a political event. We invite 501(c)(3) supporters to attend in their personal capacity.

The next 12 days could change the direction of the country

I just spent 72 hours at a major conference with a lot of the smartest leaders in the progressive movement. We celebrated. We strategized. I got to congratulate Senators-elect Scott Colom and Peggy Flanagan in person. I got to hug grassroots leaders from states like Ohio and North Carolina. And I learned something very wonky and important.

Here’s the scoop, as explained to me by Leah Greenberg, who co-runs Indivisible:

“In order to pass major legislation on democracy and everything we care about, we need to reform the filibuster. Our best chance to reform the filibuster is to have a Senate Majority Leader who is willing to lead boldly. That’s why we need Chris Van Hollen to lead the Senate instead of Chuck Schumer.”

We have until December 1 — just 12 days — to support Van Hollen’s audacious campaign. That’s when Senate Democrats will vote by secret ballot on our next Senate Majority Leader.

It’s important for Senators to hear from Democratic donors, large and small. That means you.

Senators leave D.C. for Thanksgiving recess on Friday, so we need to act fast. Our friends at Indivisible, Black Voters Matter, and Working Families Party, along with MVP partners in key states, are organizing their members and political connections to support Van Hollen’s challenge. But it’s important for Senators to hear from Democratic donors, large and small, who propelled this month’s victories. That means you.

Together, MVP partners, donors, volunteers, and friends have a key role to play. That’s why I called the MVP team and said, “We need to have an emergency briefing with our donors right now.”

62 MVP partners have weighed in so far, and 100% of them want to see Schumer replaced.

We also surveyed MVP’s partner organizations. So far, 62 partners have replied, and 100% of them said they want to see Schumer replaced. (By comparison, 67% said they wanted Biden replaced after his bad debate performance in 2024.)

We’d love to hear from you too: Take our quick survey to share your thoughts. (Spoiler alert: It also explains how you can contact your Senators to support Van Hollen right now.)

Why would we want to replace Chuck Schumer?

Chuck Schumer is a talented Senate leader, tactician, and fundraiser. However, many view him as overly risk-averse, beholden to special interests, out of touch with the populist, anti-establishment mood of the American people, and not committed to leading boldly in a period that requires bold leadership.

To win real change, we need the Senate to end the filibuster (ideally in 2027), pass bold legislation, fight visibly against wrongdoing, and show up in a way that meets the scale of the crisis in our country and in the lives of the American people.

Schumer’s brand also carries a lot of baggage with independents and progressives alike. Voters across the spectrum voted for change, and he represents the unpopular status quo.

Drop Site whip count for Senate Majority Leader: Schumer leaning 16, Van Hollen leaning 10, undecided 23, no position 6, race not called 1; 28 votes to win

Screenshot: Drop Site

What’s the state of play? Is this even possible?

Yes. Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) is challenging Schumer. He’s the underdog, but he has been gaining momentum quickly since his announcement last week. You can follow the latest whip count from Drop Site.

Strategically, even if we lose (and we know it’s an uphill battle!), waging this campaign will build pressure on Schumer and other Senators to be more responsive on issues like reforming the filibuster and passing bold, popular policies.

Running this campaign is itself a win for our democracy.

By joining with allies (partners, donors, and elected leaders) in a shared campaign, we’re also strengthening our collective muscles for future fights, so we can be heard above the deafening roar of lobbyists and big money corrupting our political system. Running this campaign is itself a win for our democracy.

Why Chris Van Hollen?

Van Hollen is the only candidate challenging Schumer for Senate Majority Leader, and he’s promising to lead boldly. (Check out his inspiring announcement video.) Here’s how the two have shown up differently on some major recent decisions:

  • Status quo vs. change: Schumer represents the status quo. Voters want change, and that’s the heart of Van Hollen’s campaign.
  • Immigration: Schumer counseled Democrats not to talk about immigration. Van Hollen went to El Salvador to advocate for Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Maryland resident deported by Trump.
  • Spending fights: Schumer compromised on the spending bills, and we didn’t get what we wanted on extending ACA subsidies or reining in ICE. Van Hollen wanted to fight harder.
  • Michigan’s Senate race: Schumer recruited Haley Stevens in the Michigan Senate primary. She lost the primary and endorsed the Republican. Van Hollen was the second Senator to endorse Abdul El-Sayed, now Michigan’s Senator-elect. He said Democrats were “too cautious, too rudderless, too attached to poll-washed and pundit-rinsed and donor-dried messages,” and he has been a leader in urging the party to move beyond “spineless politics.”

What are the risks of replacing Schumer?

The two biggest concerns are that Schumer is in a category by himself in both fundraising (especially from larger and more moderate donors) and Senate tactics. These are real potential downsides.

However, there’s a credible political case that attention and authenticity are becoming even more important than money in winning the hearts and minds of most Americans, especially younger voters, and that bold leadership will matter more than tactical expertise in the coming years.

No one can predict with certainty which path will be better in the long run. This is a choice between two different leaders and two different directions.

Why is MVP weighing in on federal decisions like this?

In the summer of 2024, MVP polled our partners on whether we should ask Biden to step aside. A supermajority said yes. We shared the results publicly in Politico, and they were cited to Democratic leaders as a sign that grassroots organizers (not just donors and pundits) wanted Biden to step aside.

More broadly, we’re looking for better ways to amplify the voices of the 500+ local organizations MVP funds in national decision-making, and to further our work to transform the Democratic Party into a party that responds to and delivers for all Americans and communities. The contest for Senate Majority Leader is an important opportunity for MVP partners and donors to make their voices heard at the national level.

At least five of our national partners (Indivisible, Working Families Party, MoveOn, Black Voters Matter, and P Street) have weighed in on this race in different ways, and every one of the 62 state-based partners who answered our survey wants to see Schumer replaced.

With so much at stake at the federal level over the next three years, this probably won’t be the last time we ask you to weigh in as MVP donors on federal decisions. We hope it’s one more way we can all be more powerful together in creating the change we need to see, at all levels, for the American people.

Join us Friday

RSVP here to join us on Friday, November 20, learn about the stakes of this fight, and find out how you can plug into this future-shaping effort right now.

Thank you for engaging with this on top of everything else you do!

Billy

Billy Wimsatt, MVP Executive Director
(On behalf of the MVP team)

Want posts emailed to your inbox?

Subscribe to our Substack.

Stay connected

Sign up for timely event invites and updates on the work of MVP and our grantee partners. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.