FAQStrategyUpdated November 20, 2026

Does MVP support replacing Sen. Chuck Schumer with Sen. Chris Van Hollen as Senate majority leader?

Yes. Movement Voter Project (MVP) supports Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) in his challenge to Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) for Senate majority leader. Senate Democrats, including newly elected senators, vote by secret ballot on December 1, and the winner needs a majority of the caucus.

Why would we want to replace Chuck Schumer?

Schumer is a talented Senate leader, tactician, and fundraiser. But to win both policy progress and electoral power, we need a Senate that ends the filibuster, passes bold legislation, and fights visibly against wrongdoing. Voters across the spectrum just voted for change, and Schumer represents the status quo. He’s also deeply unpopular: Only about a quarter of Americans view him favorably, and about half view him unfavorably.

Why is MVP weighing in on this? Isn’t this outside of MVP’s lane?

In short: A successful outside game depends on a strong inside game. What happens in Washington shapes what’s possible for the hundreds of year-round organizing groups we fund.

As MVP Founder and Executive Director Billy Wimsatt put it in our November 20 emergency briefing:

“Making structural changes to Senate leadership and the filibuster is what’s going to allow us to pass popular legislation that will give the American people a reason to support Democrats. Because as we’ve seen, when Democrats don’t deliver for the American people, bad things happen.”

MVP has done this before. In the summer of 2024, we polled our partners on whether to ask President Biden to step aside. A supermajority said yes. We shared the results publicly in Politico, where they were cited to Democratic leaders as a sign that grassroots organizers (not just donors and pundits) wanted him to step aside.

More broadly, we’re looking for better ways to amplify the voices of our grantee partners in national decision-making, and to further the work we’ve begun to transform the Democratic Party into a party that responds to and delivers for all Americans and communities. The race for Senate majority leader is an important opportunity for MVP partners and donors to make their voices heard at the national level.

What do MVP’s partners and donors think?

As of November 20, 95% of the more than 80 MVP partners who’ve answered our survey want new leadership. So do 89% of the 200 donors, volunteers, and supporters who’ve responded. National partners including Indivisible, Working Families Party, MoveOn, Black Voters Matter, and P Street have weighed in too.

What makes Van Hollen the right person for the job?

Schumer just won us the Senate. Why replace the manager who just won the World Series?

Credit where it’s due: Schumer worked hard for this majority, and he recruited several strong candidates. But it was built by millions of voters, the organizers who turned them out, and a crop of exceptional candidates, many of whom stepped up on their own. PolitiFact couldn’t confirm that Schumer recruited several of this cycle’s breakout winners, and Mississippi’s Scott Colom has said it’s “not accurate” to say Schumer recruited him, crediting “the people of Mississippi” instead.

Some of leadership’s biggest bets also missed:

Why not keep Schumer two more years and plan a handoff?

We understand the appeal, and several of our supporters have suggested this. But Schumer hasn’t said whether he’ll run again in 2028, so a handoff isn’t a given. We’ve also learned lessons the hard way about waiting too long for transitions, from President Biden to Justice Ginsburg.

And, just as importantly, what Senate Democrats do and how they do it during the final two years of Trump’s presidency will determine the outcomes of the 2028 elections. We need a majority leader who can provide bold leadership that reflects the populist, anti-establishment mood of the American people.

Isn’t Schumer the party’s best fundraiser?

This is a real tradeoff. Schumer is in a class by himself as a fundraiser, especially with larger and more moderate donors. But Van Hollen has chaired both the House and Senate Democratic campaign committees, so he knows how to raise money too. And attention and authenticity increasingly matter as much as money, especially with younger voters.

Is Van Hollen too progressive for the swing-state seats Democrats just won?

We don’t think so, and neither do some of the senators who just won those seats. Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, a moderate, has backed Van Hollen, and incoming senators from Illinois, Maine, and Kansas have said they won’t vote for Schumer. Van Hollen also led Senate Democrats’ campaign committee in 2018, when the party had to defend seats in states President Trump had won.

Shouldn’t Democrats be uniting instead of infighting?

Yes, Democrats absolutely must unite in order to get big things done. But unity comes from leaders who have earned the confidence of senators, the base, and the public. A contested leadership race is a healthy part of small-d democracy. This isn’t a progressive-vs-moderate fight. Moderates like Elissa Slotkin and new senators from red states are declining to back Schumer too.

Isn’t this a decision for senators to make among themselves?

Senators cast the votes, but everyone who helped build this majority has a stake in how it leads. We think voters, organizers, communities, and donors large and small all deserve a voice.

What if Van Hollen loses? Will this hurt MVP’s partners?

He’s the underdog, and this is an uphill battle. But the campaign builds pressure on every senator to commit to filibuster reform and bold, popular policies. As Indivisible puts it, “This cannot be a change in title without a change in approach.” Our relationships with senators are built on years of shared work to win elections, and whoever leads the Senate in January, we’ll keep working alongside them and backing the grassroots organizers who hold leaders accountable.

I disagree with MVP on this. Do you still want me involved?

Absolutely, and we thank you for telling us! We all want Democrats to deliver for people and protect our democracy. Disagreeing on one decision doesn’t change that.

How can I help Van Hollen win?

Follow the latest whip count from Drop Site, and read our November 19 blog post for more.

What happens after December 1?

Whoever wins, we’ll keep pushing for filibuster reform and bold, popular policy.

Stay connected

Sign up for timely event invites and updates on the work of MVP and our grantee partners. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.